Suggested Response - Q3

**A carbonated dilution water tank is connected to a main, which feeds a pump with an NPSHR of 3 m water. The pump inlet is 1 m below the tank outlet, and the suction line is 20 m long and has a linear pressure drop of 0.5 kPa/m. The equilibrium pressure associated with the dissolved CO2 content is 0.8 bar g, and atmospheric pressure is 100 kPa.

What is the minimum headspace pressure you would require to ensure the tank empties without the pump cavitating?

Response:

Let us look at the problem with a sketch (below).

pump

To avoid pump cavitation, we need to ensure that:

begin mathsize 14px style text NPSH end text subscript straight A greater or equal than NSPH subscript straight R end style

For cavitation to occur:

NPSHA = NPSHR

As the answer is required in pressure units, we convert NPSHA into NPSPA:

begin mathsize 14px style text NPSH end text subscript straight A equals NPSH subscript straight A cross times space 9.81 cross times 1 comma 000 end style

So, for cavitation to occur:

begin mathsize 14px style text NPSP end text subscript straight A equals NPSP subscript straight R equals 3 cross times 9.81 cross times 1 comma 000 end style

During cavitation there is no phase change, but gas evolution can occur. Therefore we use equilibrium pressure (PEQ) instead of vapour pressure.

By definition:

begin mathsize 14px style text NPSP end text subscript straight A equals straight P subscript straight s minus straight P subscript EQ end style

Where Ps is manometric pressure in the suction side of the pump, and PEQ is the equilibrium pressure.

Rearranging, we get:

begin mathsize 14px style text P end text subscript straight s equals NPSP subscript straight A plus straight P subscript EQ end style

As we know the NPSPA for cavitation, and PEQ was given:

Ps = 29.43 + 80 

Ps = 109.43

This means that the system is at risk of cavitation if the pressure in the suction side of the pump drops below 109.43 kPa.

We can now use Bernoulli’s equation between the bottom of the tank and suction side of the pump to find the required pressure in the tank headspace:

begin mathsize 14px style text P end text subscript headspace plus straight rho cross times straight g cross times straight h subscript tank space bottom end subscript minus increment straight P subscript friction equals straight P subscript straight S plus straight rho cross times straight g cross times straight h subscript pump end style

We can rearrange the equation to calculate the PH/S when cavitation occurs:

begin mathsize 14px style text P end text subscript headspace space equals straight P subscript straight S plus straight rho cross times straight g cross times left parenthesis straight h subscript pump minus straight h subscript tank space bottom end subscript space right parenthesis plus increment straight P subscript friction end style

Frictional losses can be expressed as:

begin mathsize 14px style text ∆P end text subscript friction space equals straight L cross times 0.5 end style

We replace to get:

begin mathsize 14px style text P end text subscript headspace equals 109.43 plus 9.81 cross times 1 comma 000 left parenthesis 0 minus 1 right parenthesis plus 20 cross times 0.5 end style

begin mathsize 14px style text P end text subscript headspace equals 109.43 minus 9.81 plus 10 end style

begin mathsize 14px style text P end text subscript headspace equals 109.62 space kPa left parenthesis straight g right parenthesis end style


So, the pump will not cavitate if tank headspace pressure is above 109.62 kPa.

You have completed 0% of the lesson
0%